October 15, 2025 Guide

Huntsville’s Ultimate Comfort Food Trail

Huntsville's Comfort Food: Your Fall-to-Winter Culinary Escape

As autumn's crisp air gives way to winter's embrace, there's no better time to discover Huntsville's remarkable dining scene. Our Muskoka town has transformed into a culinary destination where comfort food reigns supreme, offering everything from hearty classics to innovative twists on beloved favourites. With a wide range of exceptional restaurants serving soul-warming dishes perfect for the cooler months, Huntsville invites food lovers to embark on a delicious journey that will warm both body and spirit.

Huntsville Brewhouse

Huntsville's Comfort Food A-Z

3 Guys and a Stove serves up their signature Curry Pumpkin & Sweet Potato, a beloved staple on their menu since 1996 that perfectly captures the essence of fall flavours.

Pumpkin Soup

Allora Muskoka elevates comfort dining with their Ricotta Gnocchi, featuring pillowy dumplings in a truffled wild mushroom cream sauce with basil, garlic, and parmigiano.

Boston Pizza puts a creative spin on two Canadian classics with their Spicy Perogy Pizza, topped with sour cream, bacon, Cactus Cut Potatoes, pizza mozzarella, cheddar, and green onions.

C'est Cheese takes the Canadian classic poutine to new heights with their Gourmet Poutine, crafted with premium ingredients and expert preparation.

Chuck's Roadhouse delivers tender pork back ribs glazed with their signature Chuck's BBQ sauce—pure comfort in every sticky, delicious bite.

Compass Grill & Lounge offers an indulgent experience with their AAA Tomahawk Steak, a massive 45-ounce cut aged for 45 days and served with Bordelaise sauce, sautéed wild mushrooms, duck fat fingerling confit, summer corn puree, and asparagus.

Steak

Drift Kitchen + Bar specializes in Slow Roasted Prime Rib served with au jus, Yorkshire pudding, mustards, and horseradish—a classic done exceptionally well.

East Side Mario's serves up their impressive 12 Layer Lasagna, featuring one pound of house-made pasta with 12 layers of pizza mozzarella and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, rich meaty bolognese, creamy Alfredo, mini meatballs, fresh pasta, and Mario's Signature Tomato Sauce.

Farmer's Daughter offers Scalloped Three Potato; a classic dish made with thinly sliced potatoes in a creamy sauce that defines comfort food.

Govinda's Kitchen serves their Rajma Rice Bowl, featuring red kidney beans cooked in a gravy of tomatoes and aromatic spices with basmati rice.

Huntsville Brewhouse combines multiple comfort favourites with their Pulled Pork Mac 'n' Cheese, featuring Pilsner, a four-cheese blend, jalapeños, crispy onions, and a hint of Spark House BBQ sauce.

Kelsey's Original Roadhouse serves Chicken Fried Chicken—two pieces of hand-breaded buttermilk marinated and seasoned chicken breast smothered in creamy Roadhouse chicken gravy.

Main St. Local Kitchen puts a bold twist on a classic with their Cowboy Chili, featuring a beef chili base topped with Jimmy's Meats Bratwurst sausage, cheese, and sour cream with seasonal vegetables and your choice of roasted or mashed potatoes.

Main St Local Cowboy Chili

Maple Pub celebrates the classics with their Classic Burger, topped with lettuce, tomato, pickle and sliced red onion.

Classic Burger

Marigold Unique Flavours brings warmth with their Butter Chicken, featuring tandoori boneless chicken pieces in a fenugreek tomato sauce with cream.

Moose Delaney's Sports Bar & Grill offers The Parmer, featuring breaded buttermilk chicken breast fried to golden perfection, topped with marinara sauce, melted mozzarella, and parmesan on a bed of noodles with toasted garlic bread.

Mottbora proves that comfort food is personal with their wide variety of sushi options.

Music on Main serves Violetta's Polpetto, featuring Nonna's secret recipe with a blend of beef and pork for meatballs so good they've reportedly started bar brawls over the last one!

On the Docks Pub delivers classic Perogies stuffed with potato and cheese, baked with bacon, onion, and cheese, and served with sour cream.

Portuguese House warms souls with their Fish Stew, loaded with scallops, mussels, clams, shrimp, salmon, white fish, and potatoes in a rich tomato broth.

Seng's Thai Cuisine offers Pad Thai, a popular Thai noodle dish featuring stir-fried rice noodles with chicken and shrimp, egg, tofu, and bean sprouts in an aromatic tamarind sauce, served with crunchy peanuts and lime.

Slice of Muskoka keeps it simple with their Muskoka Grill—white bread with shredded cheddar grilled until golden, popular with children and adults alike, with the option to add peameal bacon for a heartier version.

Smokin' Hot BBQ features their Brisket, smoked for 12-16 hours and best enjoyed with a side of Julie's Mac & Cheese.

Smokin Hot Brisket

Stacked brings sweetness to comfort food with their Cookie Butter Pancakes—three fluffy pancakes topped with Biscoff spread, Biscoff crumble, and vanilla icing.

Swiss Chalet serves their famous Chicken Pot Pie with slow-roasted rotisserie chicken in a rich, creamy sauce topped with light, flaky pastry, served with a dinner roll and your choice of side.

Tall Trees elevates poutine with their Confit Duck Poutine, featuring house-made spätzle topped with tender duck confit and cheese curds.

Tall Trees Confit Duck Poutine

That Little Place by the Lights keeps it traditional with their Spaghetti & Meatballs, featuring handmade meatballs and meat sauce.

Little Place Spaghetti

The Birches offers 2 Warm Giant Buttered Pretzels served with warm infused cheese sauce and mustard for dipping—perfect for sharing or not.

The China House serves satisfying Pork Fried Rice that's savoury, satisfying, and thoroughly hearty.

The Family Place Restaurant & Pizza delivers The Carnivore Pizza loaded with pepperoni, salami, bacon, ham, sausage, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.

The Mill on Main features Guinness Lamb Stew made with seasonal root vegetables and served with garlic toast—the perfect dish for a chilly evening.

Wing's Port Bar & Grill specializes in Chicken Wings served in a wide variety of flavours to suit every taste.

Wimpy's Diner serves up Breakfast Poutine, loading home fries with three scrambled eggs, bacon, ham, peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, and hollandaise.

Beyond the Table: Fall Adventures Await

While Huntsville's dining scene will keep your taste buds delighted, the town's late fall outdoor activities provide the perfect appetite-builders between meals. Explore stunning hiking trails at Arrowhead Provincial Park, Limberlost Forest & Wildlife Reserve, and Algonquin Provincial Park, where peaceful trails wind through pristine wilderness. Art enthusiasts will love the Group of Seven Outdoor Gallery tour, featuring large-scale reproductions of iconic Canadian paintings set against the landscapes that inspired them. As darkness falls earlier, Muskoka: Home of the Stars offers guided astronomy tours under some of Ontario's clearest night skies. For unique animal encounters, enjoy horse-drawn wagon rides at Back of Beyond Equine Centre or take a memorable goat walk at Muskoka Goat Away—both experiences that blend outdoor adventure with charming local flavour.

Big Dipper

Entertainment to Complement Your Culinary Journey

The Huntsville Festival of the Arts enriches your visit with world-class entertainment all fall long. The lineup features an impressive roster of Canadian talent, including the James Barker Band on October 24, followed by the folk duo Madison Violet on October 26. Blues legend Colin James Trio takes the stage November 28, while December brings festive performances including Hawksley Workman's "Almost a Full Moon" shows, Dallas Smith & His Band Unplugged, Jann Arden's Christmas Tour on December 13 and Jeff Martin of The Tea Party to round out the year on December 15. With venues ranging from the intimate Algonquin Theatre to Deerhurst Resort, these performances add cultural richness to your comfort food adventure.

Make It a Getaway

With so many incredible restaurants to explore and activities to enjoy, experiencing Huntsville's comfort food scene properly requires more than a day trip. Booking an overnight stay allows you to savour multiple meals without worrying about the drive home, enjoy an evening performance, wake up to a hearty breakfast, and truly immerse yourself in the town's welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're planning a romantic weekend, a friends' getaway, or a solo culinary adventure, Huntsville's accommodations range from cozy to luxurious, ensuring you'll find the perfect place to rest between delicious meals. This fall and winter, treat yourself to the warmth, flavour, and hospitality that make Huntsville a true comfort food destination.

Plan Your Adventure

Plan your perfect getaway to Huntsville! Book your stay now and start exploring the charm of Muskoka.

huntsville adventures

Newsletter

Stay up to date with our latest news

We would like to respectfully acknowledge that we are on the traditional territory of the Anishinaabeg, specifically the Chippewa, Ojibwa and Potawatomi peoples, under the terms of the Robinson-Huron Treaty #61 of 1850, and the Williams Treaties of 1923.

We are grateful to be here. We hope you are too.

Together, we honour all Indigenous peoples – First Nations, Métis and Inuit – for their cultures, their languages, their wise teachings and ways of being, their stewardship and protection of the lands and waters - and life - that have shaped this country since time began.

Together, we commit to acknowledge, to learn, to educate, to create opportunity and to honour sacred places, and to take actions toward real Truth and Reconciliation in support of our commitment to wellness for all, and to walking the path together in respect, peace and harmony for future generations.

G’chi miigwech. Thank you very much.

Copyright 2025 Huntsville Municipal Accommodation Tax Association

Top